Peer Review Process
Research articles or Manuscripts submitted to Tadrib: Jurnal Pendidikan Agama Islam are initially reviewed by the editors for general fit with the Tadrib focus and scope and for the writing quality. Only those research articles meeting the Tadrib focus and scope will be sent to reviewers for a double blind review. Review time is typically 4-6 months. Two reviewers will be assigned to evaluate the research articles or manuscripts on the basis of their expertise. Reviewers are expected to return their reviews within 4 weeks. A third reviewer will be appointed in case one of the reviewers disagrees upon the quality of the research article for publication. The assigned reviewers evaluate the research articles by using a standard manuscript evaluation form. They are required to treat all the information in the research articles as confidential. Views of the assigned reviewers serve as a guide to Tadrib editors to make a final decision on the research articles. Final decision always belongs to Tadrib editors. Those manuscripts that are judged by the editors and assigned editors to be inappropriate are rejected promptly without external reviews.
The editors then make a decision based on the reviewers' advice, from among several possibilities:
|Accept as written without any revisions|
|Accept with minor revisions (a second round of review is not necessary)|
|Accept with major revisions (a second round of review will be necessary)|
|Reject (the paper is not suitable for publication)|